Christians can disagree profoundly over political views. How is that possible? And how should you respond? I believe that what the Bible says about the disciples of Jesus can lead us towards an answer.
Many people can be very concerned about politics. It was no different among Jesus’ disciples. It is quite possible that James preferred to talk about sport and that Thomas preferred to wander through the hills of Galilee and that Judas, as the financial man, was especially interested in the stock market reports. But at least two of them were deeply involved in politics. And in a totally different way.
Among the disciples of Jesus was “Matthew the tax collector” (Matthew 10:3). He collected taxes for the occupying power, the Romans. With that he earned a lot of money and with it he made himself very unpopular with his fellow citizens. He undoubtedly often had to explain why he did so.
In the following verse, “Simon Kananites” is mentioned, that is Aramaic for Simon the Zealot. In all probability he belonged to the party that most fanatically resisted the Romans, and that led the revolt against Rome that resulted in the destruction of Jerusalem one generation later
Following Jesus transcends politics
Both Matthew and Simon, belonged to the group of 12 disciples who were always close to the Lord Jesus. It is quite possible that they both had to repent of things from their political past. It is quite possible that Matthew had to become more aware of the position of his fellow citizens who were oppressed by the Roman government. It is quite possible that Simon had to become less enthusiastic about armed resistance.
We do not know. But no doubt it was still the case that if they spent the night somewhere near a stream during their travels with the Lord Jesus and they were the last two who were awake, Simon asked Matthew: how can you justify working for the Romans? And that Matthew asked Simon: how can you justify being so militant that you run the risk of the Romans taking revenge on our fellow citizens? If they asked those questions, it is likely that they would understand each other better. But I don’t believe that they agreed over politics.
So why and how could they be disciples of the Lord Jesus together? Very simple: because following Jesus is about something that transcends politics. This is what they had to preach, it is written in verse 7: the Kingdom of heaven is near! The kingdom of heaven is the term Matthew uses for the kingdom of God. And then they had to make that kingdom visible.
Health care as an example
If you apply that calling to be busy for the kingdom of God to a specific group, people who are sick, you could say that Christians can do the following:
Step 1: we invite everyone to believe in Jesus, including the sick.
Step 2: we pray for the sick that God heals them.
Step 3: we nurse the sick.
Step 4: we establish hospitals.
Step 5: we organize health care. This last step brings you to politics. That is a good and even a necessary step to take. But in contrast to the other steps, Christians can confront each other here. In politics, you can come to a different view because you can disagree about how safe or dangerous something is; about what works better, government or free market; about what is more important, individual freedom or security for the group; about whether letting people in from other cultures is primarily a threat or an enrichment; about what standards you can impose on people, and what they should have a free choice in; about whether it is best to realize those ideals through a Christian or a non-Christian party.
Christians can differ over politics
There is no direct line from being a Christian to the vast majority of political views. It is there for the sake of the sanctity of life. Why euthanasia is not good, and to an even greater extent why abortion is not good, must and may be proclaimed with as much force from a pulpit as from a political cathedral.
But on almost all other points, there are a number of intermediate steps between your religious conviction and your political conviction that make people who love the Lord God wholeheartedly come to different political points of view. I would say: fight for it if you are truly convinced that you are right.
But how are you supposed to deal with it when you face each other as brother and sister? It is sad when Christians write each other off because of different political views. That is not the intention. This example, with Matthew the tax collector and Simon the Zealot together proclaiming and making visible the kingdom of God, implicitly makes a few things clear to us.
The first is: you can both long for the best possible world, but still differ greatly in your conviction of how to get there. Paint the picture of the new earth. From left to right in politics everyone will say: that’s where we want to go! If you disagree about how it can most resemble the new earth here, you don’t make an enemy of each other. It means that one of two is mistaken. And of course it is always possible that you are.
The second is that we realize that our politics, although we would always be right, is not going to bring that new earth. So don’t take it too seriously. There is a lot that precedes politics. And there is a lot that goes beyond politics.
If we realize that, it should also be possible to be brothers and sisters in the church with very different political views, without condemning each other and looking at each other in a biased way.
Christians agree on many important things
Think about all those things Matthew the tax collector and Simon the Zealot agree on before they come to politics. Telling people about Jesus. Praying for people. Helping people. Setting up organizations to help people.
That’s a lot! That is where we find our unity as Christians. Christians who vote on the left and Christians who vote on the right agree on all these things.
The kingdom of heaven is more important than the earthly land you belong to. And if you are committed to that kingdom, then you know for sure that you are on the right side. You do that by telling people about Jesus. You do that by praying that God shows His power. You do that by loving your neighbor as yourself. You do that by working for and giving to organizations that are committed to alleviate people’s needs.
In the meantime we pray for wisdom for our Christian brothers and sisters who feel called by God to seek the good for society through politics as well.